A new study of coronavirus patients in some New York hospitals has raised doubts over the effectiveness of ventilators in saving critically ill patients.
According to the study published Wednesday by JAMA Network, around 88 per cent of patients put on a ventilator in a New York hospital system died.
The researchers analyzed data from 5,700 patients who were hospitalized from March 1 to April 4 through Northwell Health, the largest health system in New York.
Northwell has 12 hospitals across New York City, Long Island and Westchester County.
Of those patients, 2,634 were discharged or had died by the end of the study, and 320 patients with a recorded outcome were put on ventilators.
Nearly 9 in 10 of those ventilated patients died.
But age made a difference. Around 76% of ventilated patients between the ages of 18 and 65 died.
And 97%, of ventilated patients over the age of 65 died, according to the report.
Of the 2,634 patients, ventilated or not, about 21% died, according to the researchers
But that meant the majority, or 3,066, of the patients were still hospitalised when the study ended, which could have “biased the findings,” the authors wrote.
The researchers found that among the patients that were hospitalised, the most common underlying conditions were hypertension (around 56.6%), obesity (around 41.7%) and diabetes (around 33.8%).
The bleak statistics don’t imply that the ventilators caused harm, said senior author Karina Davidson, senior vice president and professor at the Feinstein Institutes for Medical Research at Northwell Health.
Rather, “patients who are put on ventilators typically have more severe disease,” and are therefore likelier to die, Davidson told Live Science in an email. “Mechanical ventilators are not dangerous, and in many cases, are life saving machines.”
The findings were published April 22 in the journal JAMA.
